Back To Menu
Accolade
ACCLAIM
Please find the results of your search below. You may refine your search using the form to the right.
Page 20 of 72
ACCOLADE RESULTS
94 points
2021 Donnafugata Isolano Dolce&Gabbana
Danielle Callegari, Wine Enthusiast, September 2025
“Flinty and herbaceous on the nose, then sweet and indulgent with ripe peach and sugared grapefruit on the palate, all electrified by acid and salt—an exciting, thoroughly enjoyable expression of Carricante.”
92 points
2022 Donnafugata Bell'Assai
Wine Enthusiast, September 2025
“Sweet, dense strawberry fruit leather and pomegranate syrup are lit up by salt and pepper and a spicy warmth that characterizes both the nose and the palate. Expressions of pure Frappato are tragically few in this world and this one performs out of class at this price.”
90 points
2024 Donnafugata Anthìlia
Eric Guido, Vinous, July 2025
“A remarkably pretty blend of lemon oil, rosemary and crushed green apple wafts up from the 2024 Bianco Anthìlia. The palate is soothingly round, with a salty flourish contrasted by white pit fruits as perfumed inner florals swirl throughout. It finishes dry yet fresh, with tropical citrus and a floral resonance that linger. The 2024 Bianco Anthìlia aims to please and has a beautiful balance that makes it enjoyable at the dinner .”
91 points
2024 Donnafugata SurSur
Eric Guido, Vinous, July 2025
“The 2024 Grillo Sur Sur entices with a mix of candied lime, green melon, mint and chalk dust. Round and supple, it shows a tinge of sour citrus for balance as ripe orchard fruits further soothe the senses. Pleasantly sweet, it tapers off perfumed with admirable length, leaving nuances of kiwi and spice to fade slowly. A total pleasure to taste.”
93 points
2022 Colomé El Arenal Malbec
Aaron Romano, Wine Spectator, July 2025
“Builds a complex tapestry of alluring aromas and flavors including rose hip, floral red currant, guava, mace and Mission fig on a texturally appealing frame, with a saline accent lending mouthwatering freshness that allows the flavors to linger around structured tannins, plus late hints of graphite and dark chocolate. Drink now through 2038. ”
91 points
2024 Colomé Estate Torrontés
Tim Atkin, Tim Atkin, June 2025
“Picked in late January to counteract the heat of the 2024 vintage, this mostly comes from the La Brava vineyard at 1,750 metres, blended with 5% from Colomé’s home vineyard at 2,300 metres. White flower aromas lead you into a palate of lime, kiwi fruit and clementine, with good texture on the palate and a broad, slightly oily finish. Classic warm climate Torrontés. 2025-27”
92 points
2022 Colomé Estate Malbec
Matthew Luczy, Robert Parker's Wine Advocate, May 2025
“The 2022 Estate Malbec combines four vineyards ranging from 1,700 meters to 3,100 meters above sea level and matured for 15 months in both new and used barrique. An inky nose of opaque fruits, tobacco leaves, fresh herbs and turned earth introduces a dense, compact palate with a mineral-tinged core. It concludes with a long, rich finish framed with taut, sturdy tannins.”
91 points
2022 Colomé Estate Malbec
Virginie Boone, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2025
“The 2022 Malbec Estate is an impressive representation of the variety from this northern appellation, brawny, beefy, and herbal, with a spicy intensity of dark, earthy black fruit. The finish is moderate in length and continues an earthy, herbal theme. The wine should age another 7-10 years.”
92 points
2023 Colomé Auténtico Malbec
Aaron Romano, Wine Spectator, June 2025
“Opens with bold notes of molasses, olive and Mission fig but then reveals a core of fresh berries and plum. Turns savory on the finish, adding dried tobacco and loam details, with structured tannins. Nice length. Drink now through 2036.”
91 points
2023 Colomé Auténtico Malbec
Virginie Boone, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2025
“The 2023 Malbec Colome Autentico is a brawny, full-bodied wine with good acidity and floral characteristics marked by its sophisticated structure and length. From the depths of Salta, it shows tremendous concentration and age-worthiness; cellar through 2037.”
94 points
2023 Colomé Auténtico Malbec
Tim Atkin, Tim Atkin, July 2024
“Auténtico sees no wood at all and is something of a homage to Colomé’s previous owner, Raúl Dávalos Senior, who hated oak-aged wines. Sappy and refreshing, it’s a bright, energetic, concrete-fermented style with wild thyme, plum, bramble and red berry flavours and a frame of savoury tannins. 2025-32”
94 points
2023 Colomé Auténtico Malbec
Claire Nesbitt, James Suckling, March 2025
“This dark-fruited red has smoky and salty undertones to the black-plum, black-olive and clove aromas. It’s full-bodied and concentrated, with deliciously spicy and salty character and berry-soaked tannins. Deep and compact. Drink or hold.”
90 points
2024 Amalaya Blanco
Joaquín Hidalgo, Vinous, October 2024
“A unique blend, the 2024 Torrontés - Riesling spent two months on the lees before bottling. Pale green in hue, the floral nose features notes of jasmine, orange blossom and nard. Dry, rich and refreshing, the malic mouthfeel contributes to a heightened, invigorating palate.”
91 points
2024 Amalaya Blanco
Tim Atkin, Tim Atkin, June 2025
“Torrontés and Riesling - two grapes that have plenty of perfume - might not sound like the ideal pairing, but this 85/15 blend from Finca San Isidro and Finca Las Mercedes respectively has engaging lime blossom and sherbet aromas, plenty of sappy acidity, citrus and orange peel flavours and an appealingly dry finish. 2025-27”
90 points
2023 Amalaya Blanco
James Suckling, James Suckling, May 2024
“Sliced pears, white cherries, jasmine and hints of bees wax on the nose. Medium-bodied, bright and vivid with clean acidity and mineral notes in the end. Flavorful and fresh. A blend of 85% torrontes and 15% riesling. Drink now. Screw cap.”
91 points
2023 Amalaya Blanco
Tim Atkin, Tim Atkin, July 2024
“Two aromatic grapes paired together in the same wine might sound like too much of a good thing, but this cuvée of Torrontés and 15% Riesling has always been a delight. Lime, orange zest and a hint of tropical fruit sweetness are complemented by a hint of terpenes on the palate adding a pleasant bitter twist. 2024-25.”